Trust Me, Lying Can Be a Good Thing

Here’s the truth: in about 99% of life’s situations, honesty is the best policy. But the rest of the time, lying can actually be beneficial and give you a better, happier outcome than telling the truth.

Don’t believe me? Come on, would I lie to you?

Here are 3 situations when lying is OK.

To Encourage a Child’s Fantasy

I was raised in an atheist family, and many people in the atheist community believe it’s wrong to lie to children about fantasy figures such as Santa Claus, the Tooth Fairy, and well…God. The idea is that if you lie to children about those things, then they won’t trust you or come to you with their problems in the future. You can make up your own mind about the existence of God (to me, “God” is feeling of love inside you and not a man sitting on a cloud judging us), but Santa Claus and the Tooth Fairy really do not exist.

I don’t think I was harmed by not believing in Santa Claus as a child, but I don’t think my friends were harmed by believing in him either. And while many of us have reasons to be mad at our parents, I’ve never seen someone on the news saying, “My life was ruined when my parents told me there was no Santa! Their lies destroyed me!”

So go ahead and “lie” to children about jolly old elves and fairies who give them treats for their baby teeth. Let them believe that the guy in the costume really is Mickey Mouse. Encouraging a child’s fantasy makes the world seem a bit more magical.

However, some parents may take this idea too far and lie to children about other things. I do not agree with lying to your children about what really happened to their dog or lying that mommy and daddy might get back together. Fantasy is one thing, but children deserve the truth when it comes to important aspects of their lives.

To Spare Someone’s Feelings

We’ve all done this before. If a friend asks you, “Does this make me look fat?” you’re not going to say, “Totally! Look at that muffin top!” You know that your friend already knows the truth, but she’s looking for comfort and reassurance, not brutal honestly.

If your friend asks you if she looks fat, ask her a few questions such as, “Why are you asking?” “Is there something going on?” “Do you want to talk about how you’re feeling?” She may be asking because someone insulted her, or she gained weight, or she’s looking for support. After you get some answers, suggest a way you can support her like going to the gym together or making a deal to pack healthy lunches for the week.

You could also make it clear that she’s not fat but her outfit isn’t making her look her best. Say something like, “That cut isn’t very flattering. I think you look beautiful in A-line skirts. Let’s find you something nicer.”

To Fake It ‘Til You Make It

Sometimes lying to yourself is the only way to break out of a rut and reach your goals. I once had a terrible job where my managers and coworkers constantly berated me and told me that my work was crap. It was a struggle to go into the office every day and be pleasant when I really wanted to tell them all to fuck off.

I could either sulk about my awful job or do something about it. Since I wasn’t in a position financially to quit my job, I decided to lie to myself and pretend that this horrible job was actually the best job in the world.

Every day I put on a cute outfit, did my hair and makeup, and tried to look my best. I smiled at everyone in the office. I dove into my work as if it were super exciting. I was doing the ol’ “fake it ‘til you make it” trick by pretending I had the fabulous job I wanted. I still sent my resume out to other positions, but I focused most of my energy on believing that I was already happy where I was.

Eventually, it got easier to go to the office, and the work bullies backed off. Then in one week, I was given an important client account to manage that my coworkers had been fighting for, I was offered another job in a different department, and I was offered a position at my dream company with a big raise. Everything fell into place after weeks of “lying” to myself.

Of course, I took the dream job at the other company and was very happy there for many years. But none of this would have happened unless I lied to myself and changed my attitude.

When have you lied to someone or yourself?

In the comments below, tell me a time when you used lying to your advantage.

The Editor’s Toolkit

  • Free Workshop: 3 Simple Steps to Become a Productivity Superstar
  • 25+ Printable Worksheets
  • 6 Life Editing Ebooks
  • My Favorite Books and Resources


  1. Betsy/Zen Mama on August 19, 2014 at 4:42 pm

    Great post Sage! Great title, too!
    And I couldn’t agree more on every point.
    Thanks for the inspiration!

  2. Cara on September 17, 2012 at 1:27 pm

    I was just having the Santa discussion with my sister in law over the weekend, my oldest niece found out about the lack of Santa….anyway, these situations are really true and I like the suggestions/questions you pose for the friend scenario. I’m currently “faking it till I make it” with my college class, those kids have no idea I’m teaching myself the material a day before I teach them it 🙂

    • Sage Grayson on September 18, 2012 at 8:45 am

      Haha! Those kids must think you know everything! I “fake it til I make it” all the time. It’s the only way I get things done.

      It was interesting growing up not believing in Santa when everyone else did. One kid told me that if I didn’t believe in Santa, then I must be Jewish. Huh? 🙂

  3. Molly on September 17, 2012 at 2:33 pm

    Another great post! I agree that there are situations when a lie is appropriate. I use it with my parents to keep the peace because telling them the truth about certain things just made things more stressful. It’s a balance with that, though, and I try to be honest with them about most things. There’s just some things that aren’t worth the stress & argument.

    I agree with Sarah- keeping up certain fun things with kids is a good thing. We let my stepsons find out on their own that there is no Santa, Easter Bunny, etc., and they seemed just fine. 🙂

    • Sage Grayson on September 18, 2012 at 8:41 am

      Avoiding an argument is another way I use lying, but I tell the truth if it’s something important.

      I didn’t grow up believing in fantasy characters, but I now understand how it lets kids be kids and see the world as a magical place. Why not let kids have some fun?

  4. xvavaveganx on September 17, 2012 at 6:00 am

    This is so true Sage! I 100% agree with you. I really think I need to start implementing fake it til you make it in my life. It’s such a great point about the kids too. I agree that you should lie to keep up the fantasy. I think it helps to develop imagination and creativity in kids 🙂 But I also agree that the lies should be limited strictly to fantasy situations.

    Another great post! 🙂 Hope you are doing well!

    • Sage Grayson on September 17, 2012 at 11:00 am

      Hey, Sarah! I use the “fake it til you make it” technique all the time. It makes it so much easier to get through tough situations.